Come Rack, Come Rope

Come Rack, Come Rope

I can’t remember which blogger it was who mentioned finding Come Rack Come Rope by Robert Hugh Benson for free on the Kindle (maybe Willa of Quotidian?) ; but I downloaded it and then sort of forgot about it until I decided the other day to pull it up on my trusty iPhone when I needed something to read while trapped with a nursing baby in a dark room, having finished all of the prayers I’d slated for that time. Oh what a treat it was.

The novel is set in Elizabethan England and follows the adventures of two seventeen year-old recusants (Catholics who refuse to become Protestant) in Derbyshire and is based on historical accounts though the two protagonists, Mistress Marjorie Manners and Master Robin Audrey who are secretly engaged as the novel opens, are fictional. The novel’s title comes from a letter by St Edmond Campion who also makes an appearance in the novel.  Aside from the protagonists and their immediate families, almost all the characters are historical ones, so this novel does provide a wonderful peep into the world of Catholics under Elizabeth’s persecutions. It includes a dramatic account of the death of Mary Stuart and of course stories of the martyrdoms of many Catholics and especially Catholic priests.

As the novel begins Robin’s father, a staunch Catholic gentleman, has just decided to “go to Church” because he is sick of selling off land to pay for the fines of not attending Church of England services. Robin is heartsick and seeks out his beloved because he knows she will provide him with good counsel. What kind of woman has faith strong enough that she can prod the man she loves to discover that he has a vocation to the priesthood? Marjorie Manners is a woman in a million. 

I wish that someone had handed me this novel when I was a young woman. It makes Catholicism—and especially the priesthood—romantic and exciting, a daring adventure, a cause worth dying for.  I think most teens feel a deep need for mission, for a great romantic purpose. In short, they want to save the world. I wish that as a teen I’d had a clearer sense that Mass and prayer could be actions to that end.

When I finished the novel I immediately wanted more and so went searching for more books. Somehow I also stumbled upon more information about the author as well. A fascinating character! Robert Hugh Benson was a younger son of the Archbishop of Canterbury and was ordained as a priest in the Church of England. He later converted, becoming a Catholic priest. I can see where the father-son relationship in Come Rack Come Rope might have been influenced by a turbulent relationship with his own father. He wrote a number of books including several more historical novels about England during the Reformation. Oh goody.

I have a hard time reading straight history, so often it is so dense and dry. I confess that I almost always prefer a good historical novel to get a sense of a period. It’s always a pleasure to find a new trove of them. Even better to imagine in the future sharing them with my children when they get old enough to deal with such sensitive material. I would warn sensitive souls that although the novel isn’t extremely graphic, it does depict torture and the grisly execution that was meted out to Catholic priests at the time.

Join the discussion

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  • The way you described Bella and Sophie’s differing reading habits exactly describes my two oldest girls: Cate (3) is very happy to look through books and tell her own very involved stories, whereas Gianna (now 5) wanted me to read to her for hours at that age.  I was actually just thinking about that difference last night, actually, because I read something that said second children are naturally more creative.  My oldest two (“twins”) are very creative in their own right, but I will say that Cate has a more complex imagination.  It might have something to do with being left to play on her own more than her older siblings were, or it may be because she plays all day with the older kids and picks up their imaginative habits.  Or it could just be her!  It really is intriguing to consider which parts of their personalities are influenced by their surroundings and position in the family and which are distinctly and naturally them (the old nature vs nurture!).

  • I’m not sure that I’d say Sophie is more creative than Bella. Bella does tell very elaborate stories and has a highly developed fantasy world; but very seldom are her stories directly inspired by paging through a book. Bella Sophie is a bit more whimsical and more prone to playing with language. But Sophie is often very imitative of Bella. Her imaginary characters often have the same names as Bella’s imaginary characters. Sophie will speak of “my Gina” or “my Jane” to distinguish them from Bella’s Gina and Jane. But Sophie invented Miss Jelsie, which I believe is a corruption from mishearing in excelsis deo. Sometimes it’s hard to see who is influencing whom as they play their games together. You are right that it’s fascinating to consider how much of Sophie’s personality is due to being the second child and how much is just her. Or for that matter how much of Bella is being the oldest.